Influence of System-Scale Change on Co-Alignment Comparative Accuracy in Fixed Terrestrial Photogrammetric Monitoring Systems

Photogrammetry can be a valuable tool for understanding landscape evolution and natural hazards such as landslides. However, factors such as vegetation cover, shadows, and unstable ground can limit its effectiveness. Using photos across time to monitor an area with unstable or changing ground conditions results in fewer tie points between images across time, and often leads to low comparative accuracy if single-epoch (i.e., classical) photogrammetric processing approaches are used. This paper presents a study evaluating the co-alignment approach applied to fixed terrestrial timelapse photos at an active landslide site. The study explores the comparative accuracy of reconstructed surface models and the location and behavior of tie points over time in relation to increasing levels of global change due to landslide activity and rockfall. Building upon previous work, this study demonstrates that high comparative accuracy can be achieved with a relatively low number of inter-epoch tie points, highlighting the importance of their distribution across stable ground, rather than the total quantity. High comparative accuracy was achieved with as few as 0.03 percent of the overall co-alignment tie points being inter-epoch tie points. These results show that co-alignment is an effective approach for conducting change detection, even with large degrees of global changes between surveys. This study is specific to the context of geoscience applications like landslide monitoring, but its findings should be relevant for any application where significant changes occur between surveys.