Seeing Race, Feeling Bias: Emotion Stereotyping in Multimodal Language Models

Large language models (LLMs) are increasingly used to predict human emotions, but previous studies show that these models reproduce gendered emotion stereotypes. Emotion stereotypes are also tightly tied to race and skin tone (consider, for example, the trope of the angry black woman), but previous work has thus far overlooked this dimension. In this paper, we address this gap by introducing the first large-scale multimodal study of racial, gender, and skin-tone bias in emotion attribution, revealing how modality (text, images) and their combination shape emotion stereotypes in Multimodal LLMs (MLLMs). We evaluate four open-source MLLMs using 2.1K emotion-related events paired with 400 neutral face images across three different prompt strategies. Our findings reveal varying biases in MLLMs representations of different racial groups: models reproduce racial stereotypes across modalities, with textual cues being particularly noticeable. Models also reproduce colourist trends, with darker skin tones showing more skew. Our research highlights the need for future rigorous evaluation and mitigation strategies that account for race, colorism, and gender in MLLMs.