Illuminant metamerism between natural teeth and zirconia restorations evaluated with a chromatic adaptation transform

Statement of problem Little is known about the effect of illuminant metamerism between natural teeth and zirconia restorations, despite their increasing clinical popularity. Purpose The purpose of this in vitro study was to compare illuminant metamerism between pairs of natural teeth and layered zirconia restorations and pairs of natural teeth and monolithic zirconia restorations under 10 different illuminants and analyze their metameric potential. Material and methods Spectral reflectance factors were obtained from 10 pairs of extracted natural teeth and layered zirconia restorations and 28 pairs of extracted natural teeth and monolithic multilayer zirconia restorations. Each pair showed a color match that was within the visual threshold for clinical acceptability (CIEDE2000≤1.8). A special index of metamerism for the change of illuminant (Milm) was calculated from the CIEDE2000 color difference equation. Descriptive statistics and the one-sample t test were used to analyze the results for the Milm and for both groups of layered and monolithic zirconia restorations (α=.05). Results Layered zirconia restorations reached a mean ±standard deviation value for Milm=0.3 ±0.2 and Milm=0.5 ±0.4 for monolithic zirconia restorations (P<.01). Conclusions The effect of illuminant metamerism between natural teeth and zirconia crowns was weak and generally within the clinical acceptability limit.