A review of closed-form Cramér-Rao Bounds for DOA estimation in the presence of Gaussian noise under a unified framework

The Cramér-Rao Bound (CRB) for direction of arrival (DOA) estimation has been extensively studied over the past four decades, with a plethora of CRB expressions reported for various parametric models. In the literature, there are different methods to derive a closed-form CRB expression, but many derivations tend to involve intricate matrix manipulations which appear difficult to understand. Starting from the Slepian-Bangs formula and following the simplest derivation approach, this paper reviews a number of closed-form Gaussian CRB expressions for the DOA parameter under a unified framework, based on which all the specific CRB presentations can be derived concisely. The results cover three scenarios: narrowband complex circular signals, narrowband complex noncircular signals, and wideband signals. Three signal models are considered: the deterministic model, the stochastic Gaussian model, and the stochastic Gaussian model with the a priori knowledge that the sources are spatially uncorrelated. Moreover, three Gaussian noise models distinguished by the structure of the noise covariance matrix are concerned: spatially uncorrelated noise with unknown either identical or distinct variances at different sensors, and arbitrary unknown noise. In each scenario, a unified framework for the DOA-related block of the deterministic/stochastic CRB is developed, which encompasses one class of closed-form deterministic CRB expressions and two classes of stochastic ones under the three noise models. Comparisons among different CRBs across classes and scenarios are presented, yielding a series of equalities and inequalities which reflect the benchmark for the estimation efficiency under various situations. Furthermore, validity of all CRB expressions are examined, with some specific results for linear arrays provided, leading to several upper bounds on the number of resolvable Gaussian sources in the underdetermined case.