Comparative study of modular dual 3-phase permanent magnet machines with overlapping/non-overlapping windings

For modular permanent magnet (PM) machines with overlapping (OLP) windings widely employed in wind power generation, the large torque ripple and long end winding are major issues. In order to solve these problems, PM machines with non-overlapping (NOLP) windings and redundant teeth for easy modularity are proposed in this paper. The comparative study between modular machines with these two kinds of windings is necessary and the major focus of this paper. For the sake of clarity, two modular dual 3-phase machines with 42-slots/32-poles (42S/32P) and 192S/32P combinations are chosen as examples to show the differences in terms of the machine performance. The proposed 42S/32P modular machine adopts NOLP winding, while the conventional 192S/32P one uses OLP type. Based on the results, it is found that the modular machine with NOLP winding has comparable average torque and efficiency. In the meantime, much lower torque ripple exists for the proposed modular machine regardless of the current value. The shorter and simpler end windings are beneficial to manufacturability. Moreover, the proposed modular machine with NOLP winding will be more fault-tolerant due to smaller mutual inductances between phases and larger d-axis inductance. Finally, the proposed 42S/32P modular machine is prototyped and the experiments validate the correctness of the analyses in this paper. Despite two specific examples being used, the conclusion should be generic and can be employed to modular machines with other slot and pole number combinations.