A comparison of environmental impact of various silicas using a green chemistry evaluator

To answer questions surrounding the sustainability of silica production, MilliporeSigma’s DOZNTM 2.0 Green Chemistry Evaluator was employed as it provides quantitative values based on the 12 Principles of Green Chemistry. As a first study using DOZNTM 2.0 to evaluate the greenness of nanomaterials, a range of silica types were considered and their greenness scores compared. These included low- and high-value silicas, both commercial and emerging such as precipitated, gel, fumed, colloidal, mesoporous and bioinspired silicas. When surveying these different types of silicas, it became clear that while low value silicas have excellent greenness scores, high-value silicas perform poorly on this scale. This highlighted the tension between high-value silicas that are desired for emerging markets and the sustainability of their synthesis. The calculations were able to quantify the issues pertaining to the energy-intensive reactions and subsequent removal of soft templates for the sol-gel processes. The importance of avoiding problematic solvents during processes and particularly as waste were identified. The calculations were also able to compare the amount of waste generated as well as their hazardous nature. The effects of synthesis conditions on greenness scores were also investigated in order to better understand the relationship between the production process and their sustainability.