Performance comparison of doubly salient reluctance machine topologies supplied by sinewave currents

This paper comprehensively investigates the electromagnetic performance of 3-phase, 12-slot, and 8-pole switched reluctance machines (SRMs) with different winding configurations, i.e. double/single layer, short pitched (concentrated) and fully pitched (distributed). These SRMs are supplied by sinewave currents so that a conventional 3-phase converter can be employed, leading to behavior which is akin to that of synchronous reluctance type machines. Comparisons in terms of static and dynamic performances such as d- and q-axis inductances, on-load torque, torque-speed curve, efficiency map, etc. have been carried out using two-dimensional finite element method (2-D FEM). It is demonstrated for the given size of machine considered, that for same copper loss and without heavy magnetic saturation, both single and double layer mutually coupled SRMs can produce higher on-load torque compared to conventional SRMs. Additionally, double layer mutually coupled SRM achieved the highest efficiency compared to other counterparts. When it comes to single layer SRMs, they are more suitable for middle speed applications and capable of producing higher average torque while lower torque ripple than their double layer counterparts at low phase current. Two prototype SRMs, both single layer and double layer, are built to validate the predictions.