Geographic variation in the treatment of non-ST-segment myocardial infarction in the English National Health Service: a cohort study

Objectives: To investigate geographic variation in guideline-indicated treatments for NSTEMI in the English National Health Service (NHS).

Design: Cohort study using registry data from the Myocardial Ischaemia National Audit Project. Setting: All Clinical Commissioning Groups (CCGs) (n=211) in the English NHS. Participants: 357,228 patients with NSTEMI between 1st January, 2003 and 30th June, 2013. Main outcome measure: Proportion of eligible NSTEMI who received all eligible guideline-indicated treatments (optimal care) according to the date of guideline publication. Results: The proportion of NSTEMI who received optimal care was low (48,257/357,228; 13.5%) and varied between CCGs (median 12.8%, interquartile range 0.7 to 18.1%). The greatest geographic variation was for aldosterone antagonists (16.7%, 0.0 to 40.0%) and least for use of an electrocardiogram (96.7%, 92.5 to 98.7%). The highest rates of care were for acute aspirin (median 92.8%, interquartile range 88.6 to 97.1%), and aspirin (90.1%, 85.1 to 93.3%) and statins (86.4%, 82.3 to 91.2%) at hospital discharge. The lowest rates were for smoking cessation advice (median 11.6%, interquartile range 8.7 to 16.6%), dietary advice (32.4%, 23.9 to 41.7%) and the prescription of P2Y12 inhibitors (39.7%, 32.4 to 46.9%). After adjustment for case mix, nearly all (99.6%) of the variation was due to between hospitals differences (median 64.7%, interquartile range 57.4% to 70.0%; between hospital variance: 1.92, 95% confidence interval 1.51 to 2.44; interclass correlation 0.996, 0.976 to 0.999). Conclusions: Across the English NHS, the optimal use of guideline-indicated treatments for NSTEMI was low. Variation in the use of specific treatments for NSTEMI was mostly explained by between-hospital differences in care. Performance-based commissioning may increase the use of NSTEMI treatments and, therefore, reduce premature cardiovascular deaths.