Energy metrics to evaluate the energy use and performance of water main assets

Managing aging infrastructure has become one of the greatest challenges for water utilities, particularly when faced with selecting the most critical pipes for rehabilitation from among the thousands of candidates. This paper presents a set of novel yet practical energy metrics that quantify energy interactions at the spatial resolution of individual water mains to help utilities identify pipes for rehabilitation. The metrics are demonstrated using a benchmark system and two large, complex systems. The results show that the majority of pipes have good energy performance but that an important minority of outlier pipes have low energy efficiency and high energy losses due to friction and leakage. Pumping and tank operations tend to drive energy efficiency and energy losses in pipes close to water sources, whereas diurnal variation in demand drives energy performance of mains located far away from water sources. The new metrics of energy lost to friction and energy lost to leakage can provide information on energy performance in a pipe that is complementary to the traditional measures of unit head loss and leakage flow.